THE SIMULATION WE ARE LIVING IN
by Ploum on 2026-11-19
https://ploum.net/2026-11-19-capitalist_roleplay.html
Or How We Are Roleplaying a Successful Capitalist Life
======================================================
https://ploum.net/files/matrixpod.webp
Nat wrote a piece about Copilot being the peak-oil of high technology.
Copilot is the peak oil of high technology (gemini.njms.ca)
gemini://gemini.njms.ca/gemlog/peak-oil-high-technology.gmi
I agree with Nat’s anger and the feeling of disorientation.
I’ve lived through multiple tech bubbles and, in all of them, the
"believers" were a minority. In fact, you always had a minority of vocal
believers opposing "serious seasoned people". The vast majority of the
world didn’t care much about the bubble or were exposed to it only
through mainstream media. I’ve witnessed crazy stuff, including very
influential and powerful people trying to "join the bubble". But if I
disconnected, walked out of parties or meeting or went outside, I would
see little trace of the bubble.
With the AI bubble, it seems like nearly everyone has been turned into a
believer. Around me, every single conversation seems to be about AI,
especially in non-tech circles. While my experience told me that most
industries have always been very reluctant to adopt new technologies, we
are witnessing a world where every big company, every CEO, every manager
and every teacher/academic is suddenly voluntarily sabotaging a lifetime
of experience to make sure we use an unreliable-by-design tool
everywhere even though it barely existed a couple of years ago.
From a technological perspective, this is absolute nonsense.
Remember that everything is propaganda
======================================
Reading Chomsky helped me a lot here: I was reminded that everything we
read, everything we
hear is propaganda. Those are not facts. Those are intentionally
designed messages to turn us into believers.
The current propaganda is geared toward making chatbots the new norm
because this is our current consumption bubble and the system always
needs something into which we will inject as much money as we can.
According to Chomsky, propaganda means you should always invert cause
and consequence:
- People don’t write good things about vibecoding because it works for
them, they believe it works for them because they read and need to write
good things about it.
- Chatbots are not inevitable: people try to convince themselves they
are inevitable to justify using them.
We now know that, at least for Open Source programming, AI doesn’t make
you more productive. But it makes you believe that you are. Just like
drugs make you believe you are smart and alcohol makes you believe that
you are a good driver. The productivity of LLMs is not a fact. But the
intoxication is real.
[2507.09089] Measuring the Impact of Early-2025 AI on Experienced Open-
Source Developer Productivity (arxiv.org)
https://arxiv.org/abs/2507.09089
The propaganda is not even subtle! It is transparent and sometimes
borderline parodic, like the time when an Anthropic employee recognized
that it was stupid to have an AI managing your business but you had to
prepare for that world because you had no choice.
Prepare for That Stupid World (ploum.net)
https://ploum.net/2025-12-19-prepare-for-that-world.html
Bad managers are leading the world
==================================
In the end, this is mainly propaganda to make us believe that we live in
the world as seen through the eyes of Juliuses (my word for what Ed
Zitron calls "the business idiots").
My colleague Julius (ploum.net)
https://ploum.net/2024-12-23-julius-en.html
Juliuses are people who don’t even understand that there are things to
understand. They don’t even have access to that part of consciousness
where you truly understand a concept. They live in a blurry state of
consciousness where they only care about the "next action". They
don’t have any notion of "rationality" or "logic". They believe
intuition is as good as scientific knowledge ("Oh, you are Sagittarius?
That explains why you speak like that!")
Feynman famously said that, to solve a problem, you need to:
1. Write the problem down
2. Think hard
3. Write the solution
As Feynman said, most people do everything they can to skip steps 1 and
2.
They really want to go straight to 3. That’s why AI is wonderful: it
even does what looks like step 3 for you if you are not qualified enough
to check.
But it cannot work for one simple reason: if your problem is not clear,
you will never have a good solution. Writing code is 90% about defining
the problem and all its edge cases. Writing code is taking decisions, by
essence. The same can be said for legal contracts. Lawyers are people
who write a form of code where they want to account for every
conceivable situation and decide what to do before it happens.
We are delegating our free will to remove accountability
========================================================
In his book "Éloge du bug", Marcello Vitali-Rosati draws an analogy with
the genie of Aladdin. In the story, Aladdin asks for "beautiful clothes"
and the genie obeys. Or does he?
Éloge du bug - Éditions Zones (www.editions-zones.fr)
https://www.editions-zones.fr/livres/eloge-du-bug/
In fact, the genie makes a lot of decisions about what "beautiful
clothes" are. Would they be clothes that "look expensive"? That "follow
the norms" or, on the contrary, that are completely new and creative?
Without realizing it, Aladdin completely gave up on his free will and
his own identity. From that moment, Aladdin is just a puppet in the
genie’s hands.
The whole point of vibecoding is "let an opaque proprietary algorithm
controlled by a huge economic entity take all the decisions about what
it thinks I want now and how I should live my future". It cannot work if
there’s some accountability in play. Nobody would sign a randomly
generated contract. So the trick is to remove accountability.
We have all encountered examples of "I’m not wrong, this is what AI told
me". By communicating a lot about ChatGPT mistakes and saying they take
them seriously, OpenAI is reinforcing the sense that you are not
accountable for blindly obeying ChatGPT. You can delegate your
responsibilities to them. The whole discourse about "inevitability" is
only that: it is about removing liability and responsibility. "Of course
I signed that random contract. Everyone does it. It is inevitable. And
they will make the next contract better."
Juliuses live in a world where they do everything to get immediate
benefits and avoid accountability. That’s what modern businesses are
built for: you get the money as an individual but the company pays fines
and nobody goes to jail, even if you kill millions with a defective
product (except if you mess with shareholders money,then you are
liable). At worst, you are fired (with a golden parachute if you are
high enough on the ladder).
In that regard, LLMs are a terrible engineering tool. After all, they
have random output, are unreliable by design and act randomly. But they
are perfect business tools because they remove agency, free will and
liability.
The successful capitalist roleplay
==================================
On his blog, Ron Gilbert quotes "AI feels amazing when it’s talking
about a subject you know nothing about, but is laughably wrong when you
do". The solution is thus simple: make sure nobody knows anything about
anything anymore.
My Dinner With AI (grumpygamer.com)
https://grumpygamer.com/my_dinner_with_ai/
The social media bubble was led by marketers and their view of the
world. They wanted us to believe that everybody was a marketer, that our
life should be marketed ("personal branding"), that every happy moment
was there to "advertize" how cool we are. People do not meet to have
fun, they meet to take pictures to convince the world they had fun.
The cryptocurrency bubble was led by financiers. They told us that
everything is an asset and everyone is a trader. We should all become
rich while selling assets to each other. The AI bubble is led by
management. Everyone should be the manager of a team of "agents" that
blindly obey and agree to everything we say.
The capitalist system is successfully selling us the fact that, after
our long hours at a shitty job, if we are lucky enough to have one, we
can roleplay a very successful capitalist life on a small bright screen.
Indeed, they were wrong about the VR bubble! No need for immersive
virtual reality. We are intoxicated enough by the capitalist roleplay to
break our necks while spending our nights looking at a screen smaller
than those Terry Gilliam envisioned in Brazil. At least, in Brazil, they
still had real keyboards!
Still from the movie "Brazil" (by Terry Gilliam)
https://ploum.net/files/brazil.jpg
Remember the pods in The Matrix? Turns out small addictive screens do
the job. We even pay for them! Neo is not fighting Agent Smith with a
cool leather jacket and guns. He wears a lousy t-shirt and is ignored,
frowned upon or, at best, offered social skills therapy.
When you understand that this is all propaganda, a fiction, a shared
dream (or a nightmare), that business people are all lying through their
teeth because, for them, it’s part of the game, it gradually starts to
make sense.
But it is no less frightening…
THE ANTI-MARKETING ASPECT OF THE GEMINI NETWORK
by Ploum on 2026-11-12
https://ploum.net/2026-11-12-anti-marketing-gemini.html
And why your niche should stay a niche
======================================
I like Gemini. Not the Google Chatbot but the network that existed
before Google named its product. If you are enough of a geek, you may
want to give it a try.
Creating a Blog in Gemini:// (brennan.day)
https://brennan.day/creating-a-blog-in-gemini/
Eoin is counting the number of "capsules" on the Gemini network. A
capsule is the equivalent of a "website" on the Web or a "hole" on
Gopher. It’s a personal space, a bunch of pages. Blogs become "gemlogs".
Eoin’s first observation is that the number of active capsules is slowly
growing. The network is healthy.
But his second observation is really interesting: there’s absolutely no
correlation between the number of new capsules in a given month and
articles about the Gemini protocol being promoted on the first page of
Hacker News.
Counting Capsules (spool-five.com)
gemini://spool-five.com/gemlog/2026-02-02_counting_capsules.gmi
same content but on the Web
https://spool-five.com/posts/2026-02-02_counting_capsules/
This is a confirmation of what I’ve benn trying to explain for
years: your metrics and web statistics are completely useless. The
number of visitors, the number of clicks are worthless if you are not a
marketer trying to extract money from a big brand. They don’t mean
anything.
By the way: you should really avoid Hacker News these days. The front
page is heavily manipulated to promote pro-AI stuff and bury everything
that might question wether fascism-capitalism is good.
Why is Hacker News like that? (drewdevault.com)
https://drewdevault.com/blog/Why-is-HN-like-that/
A Mozilla employee is leaving after 15 years and comes to a similar
conclusion. Mozilla is awesome because it has always been abnormal. It
is mostly used by abnormal people. This means that hiring "normal
managers" who try to make it "normal" and chase "normal" metrics is, of
course, a recipe for failure.
jr conlin's ink stained banana (blog.unitedheroes.net)
https://blog.unitedheroes.net/5751
I always failed to understand those marketing people who try to be "like
others but a bit cheaper". While all the value is being different enough
to nurture your own niche.
I completely removed statistics from my blog in 2013. At the time, I had
a very strong realisation that the blog posts that mattered most, those
I was proudest of, and those that prompted people to mail me even years
later all had mediocre statistics.
How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Web (ploum.net)
https://ploum.net/how-i-learned-to-stop-worrying-and-love-the-web/index.html
On the contrary, most of my hit, my "buzz", were quickly forgotten. But,
being addicted to statistics, I was unconsciously adapting my writing
style to improve those numbers. I was scrolling through social media
posts that were highly popular while trying to create some myself.
Closing my social media accounts and, instead, procrastinating on Gemini
had the opposite effect: making me read other ideas without caring about
reactions, about popularity. Jsreed5 made the same observation while he
was trying the Nostr protocol. While Nostr’s technicalities may be
interesting by themselves, the content on it is similar to the one found
of mainstream social networks. And our smolnet Gemini-formatted brains
cannot take it anymore!
A Geminaut's View of Nostr (jsreed5.org)
gemini://jsreed5.org/log/2026/202605/20260520-a-geminauts-view-of-nostr.gmi
We really need a simple Gemini hosting provider that would also provide
a Web version, to welcome less technical-minded people who still may
want to access a quieter, non-commercial, out-of-time virtual space.
Lot of people are trying Gemini and find that there’s no content on it,
that they can’t have their news and dopamine hit on it. Well, that’s
exactly the point.
There Is No Content on Gemini (ploum.net)
https://ploum.net/2022-10-05-there-is-no-content-on-gemini.html
The fact that only a niche minority want to use it is also part of the
point. Gemini might no be for you. That’s fine. The modern Web and even
the real world (where every device is actively working against me and
every human interaction seems to be about AI) is increasingly not for
me. So let me have my strange niche space.